Is it Cheaper to Replace Cabinets or Reface Cabinet Doors?

If you're currently remodeling your kitchen, you may be wondering whether it's better to reface or replace your cabinets. Both options have pros and cons, and it’s up to you to decide which is the better choice based on your needs, wants, and resources. 

In this article, we'll explore the key differences between refacing cabinets vs. new cabinets so you can determine which approach is right for your space. Here's everything you need to know:

What Does It Mean to Reface Cabinets vs Replace Them?

Refacing is the process of simply replacing the cabinet door and drawer fronts on the cabinet box, while replacing is the process of replacing the entire cabinet box and cabinet doors. 

All cabinets consist of a box (the inside of the cabinet) and a face (the outside front of the cabinet – the part you actually see). When you reface kitchen cabinets, you replace only the “exterior” parts of the cabinets, leaving the existing boxes underneath. That entails replacing the cabinet doors and drawer fronts, and possibly applying new paint, stain, or veneer to the cabinet face that the doors don’t cover. You choose how much or how little you want to reface, but in all cases, you work only on the outside of the cabinets and keep everything else the same.

Cost Breakdown: Refacing or Replacing Kitchen Cabinets?

Refacing costs significantly less than replacing cabinet doors, and less than you would expect. You don’t need a massive budget to make your cabinets – and by extension your whole kitchen – look how you want them to. Think of it like doing a major kitchen renovation for a fraction of the cost. 

Here’s how the costs compare: 

Material and Labor Costs

Replacing kitchen cabinets entirely is a costly project that typically requires more materials and professional assistance. You’ll need to hire installers, contractors, and possibly a plumber or an electrician. 

Homeowners who choose to reface over replace find that the process tends to be 30-50% cheaper. There's no need to hire professionals, since you can easily DIY the installation at home with the right resources. There's also less material needed to complete the project, which helps reduce waste and keep costs low.

Hidden Costs to Watch For

When replacing cabinet doors and boxes, you may find that a few structural repairs are needed during the remodel. If you decide to change the layout, you also need to consult with a contractor for a professional design. These can be costly investments that increase the overall project cost.

Refacing cabinet doors will be significantly cheaper than a remodel. However, you'll need to consider the cost of hardware upgrades, repairs, and matching drawer fronts. 

DISCOVER CUSTOM CABINET DOOR REPLACEMENT OPTIONS

How Long Does Each Option Take?

Next, you'll need to consider your personal timeline and how much time you can commit to the project. Here's how the timeline for both approaches compares:

Refacing Timeline

Most homeowners can complete a refacing project in just two to four days. If your new cabinet doors and drawer fronts arrive finished, they can typically be installed the same day. If you need to paint, stain, or add a finish to the doors, you may need a few extra days to complete the project. Overall, refacing cabinets causes minimal disruptions to your kitchen, making it great for individuals with a busy lifestyle.

Cabinet Replacement Timeline

Replacing kitchen cabinets means shutting your kitchen down from the time the current cabinets get removed until the new ones go up (unless you’re willing or able to cook in a kitchen without cabinets). It also creates a lot of noise and mess in the center of your home. This is par for the course with many home-improvement projects, of course, but it’s important to understand everything involved before the old cabinets start coming down. 

The entire process of a cabinet replacement can take anywhere from one to three weeks to complete. Before you even begin the project, you'll need to ensure you have enough time to meet with the contractor and approve the layout design changes. While making the home renovations, you may also need to hire a plumber or electrician to come to your home for repairs, which can cause unwanted delays.

Which Option Is Right for You?

So, should you reface or replace cabinets? It really depends on your needs for the space and how much time and money you can dedicate to the project.

When Refacing Makes Sense

Refacing cabinet doors is a budget-friendly alternative to replacing the entire cabinet doors, providing a fully revived finish. This is the best choice if your cabinet boxes are in great shape and show no signs of damage. This is also a great option if you like the current kitchen layout and don't want to adjust the design.  

When Replacement Is Better

Refacing updates the look of kitchen cabinets, but it doesn’t necessarily extend the life. Since you’re just replacing the front or exterior part of the cabinet—the box underneath, which provides the structure and support—is still the same age. And when the box wears out, you will need to replace the entire cabinet.

If there is any structural damage to the cabinet boxes, a replacement might be a better solution. Any warping, rot, mold, or severe damage that can't be fixed will likely need to be replaced. Replacing cabinets is also a better option if you want to change the kitchen layout or if you have the time to commit to a full kitchen remodel.

Choose the Smart Upgrade for Your Kitchen with CabinetDoors.com

If the structural integrity of your cabinet boxes is still in good shape and you like your current layout, refacing is a much better option than a cabinet replacement. This approach will revive your home aesthetic at a fraction of the cost. 

At CabinetDoors.com, all of our cabinet door replacements are custom-made and made to order. Whether you're looking to modernize your kitchen or take a more traditional approach, we have a wide selection of different styles and materials to consider for your project. We also have high-end hardware and drawer fronts. 

EXPLORE OUR COLLECTION OF CUSTOM-MADE CABINET DOORS TODAY

Frequently Asked Questions

Is replacing cabinet doors the same as refacing?

Refacing is the process of replacing the cabinet doors and drawer fronts, while replacing involves replacing the doors and the cabinet boxes. 

How long do refaced cabinets last?

Refaced cabinets purchased from a reliable cabinet door reseller can last anywhere from 10 to 20 years. The exact time will vary depending on the materials used and the wood species. 

Can I mix refacing with replacing a few damaged cabinets?

Yes, you can mix refacing with replacing if you have a few damaged cabinets. However, to achieve a seamless look, you'll need to match the new cabinetry with the existing ones.